Girls Season 2 Returns with 'It's About Time'
Written by : goodbadgeeky published Tuesday 15th January 2013
Sunday night on HBO marked the return of Hannah (Lena Dunham), Marnie (Allison Williams), Shoshanna (Zosia Mamet) and Jessa (Jemima Kirke) as they navigate the slings and arrows of living in New York City in the season two premiere of GIRLS. In the episode “It’s About Time”, Elijah (Andrew Rannells) throws a party with his new roommate Hannah, who meanwhile has all but officially broken up with Adam (Adam Driver). Marnie deals with her own dose of bad news and her mother (Rita Wilson) while Shoshanna deals with Ray (Alex Karpovsky) at the party while Jessa returns from her honeymoon. So does GIRLS retains the sincerity and unique voice of creator Lena Dunham while also maintain the quality from season one?
Ultimately that is a real interesting question.
I remember that GIRLS for me, was a refreshing series, told exclusively from the girls point of view, and it didn’t go for always cheap laughs. It was intense, it was poignant, and above all else it felt real. But when I popped GIRLS on my DVR Sunday evening, if you had to ask me in particular barely anything that happened in season one outside of Hannah being cut off from her parents and doing drugs, and pining over Adam, and maybe Marnie and Charlie (Christopher Abbott) breaking up while Jessa surprised married Thomas-John (Chris O'Dowd), I have no real sense of how season one ended.
For such a critically lauded series, one that even I, myself, critically acclaimed… why could I not remember anything that happened in the series? Why didn’t I necessarily care? For a series that was so on the nose and truly opened the insight into the life of women, I couldn’t remember anything truly of significance from the season one finale, and then again, did I really care? For a series that had it’s hooks in me, nothing of any significance stuck with me as a viewer besides basic moments. It wasn’t like Bored to Death or Game of Thrones, or The Newsroom; all series on HBO that had/have me captivated even during it’s off-seasons.
Let’s be clear: “It’s About Time” is a good episode, and it gets us right back into things with a fun and racy scene with Hannah and new boy toy Sandy (Donald Glover), and showcasing Marnie getting fired from her job. It just was upsetting for a series with such praise, my care factor was not that high. And it further questions the series beyond that, on a primitive level: is GIRLS, at least for me, as a man, more of an insight into the female mind and is interesting but on a dramatic level thatkeeps me ‘coming back to the well’ it instead comes up short? As GIRLS is not a series that screams reruns or DVD-viewing to me, but then again, that is my general feeling towards the show.
To me, sometimes the best television series are shows that have moments or episodes that are worth re-watching. Maybe not constant rewatchability, one that you could watch over and over and over again, but shows that have a sincere replayability. These types of shows range from 30 minute to 60 minute shows. Futurama is a show that is easily rewatchable at all times. L0ST, despite my love for the show, or even Treme, is a show that is like Schindler’s List as a film: it is amazing but my want to rewatch it isn’t always 100% present. Give me a year or two, and I’d be game for re-watching the series again. The love of the show is there but the want to re-watch ebbs and flows. But GIRLS doesn’t really fall into either one of those categories to me. And for me, that is what my critique is. As a series, it is a great show… when you’re watching it. Outside of that, within a few months, GIRLS is a blip on my radar. And it’s sad because when I’m watching it, I am 100% engrossed in what’s going on. Once the credits roll, I’m somewhat back to wondering when Game of Thrones or even Go On or Community is coming back on television.
About the author goodbadgeeky
Nick ‘Nitro’ Arganbright has an extreme love for a good story, whether it be in film, tv, video games, comic books, music or more and it shows in each article and podcast he produced. The titular podcast he produces is called The Good The Bad & The Geeky with co-hosts Jon Bettin and Nathan ‘DJ Meat’ Haley. The podcast has helped him make a few contacts within in the industry which he hopes to use to entertain and inform readers of his reviews on Examiner.com and The TV King, offering an average joe opinion that is often overlooked in major print and online publications. If you’d like to e-mail him, please do so at [email protected] or you can tweet him on twitter at @goodbadgeeky.goodbadgeeky's profile | goodbadgeeky's RSS feed
- A "Trio" of Uneven GLEE Stories
- ‘Survivor: Cagayan’, Episode 3: Jeremiah in the middle
- ALMOST HUMAN Almost Great
- "Brother's War" on VIKINGS
- House of Cards Season 2 Midpoint Check-in
- Leaving DOWNTON ABBEY Once More
- COMMUNITY Celebrates the "Beta Male"
- "Frenemies" Make for Drama-Filled GLEE
- ‘Survivor: Cagayan’, Episode 1: Why this season has already left a bad tast...
- "The Return" of DALLAS
- DVD Review: ‘Legit – The Complete First Season’
- DVD Review: ‘Mama’s Family – The Complete Third Season’
- DVD Review: ‘Family Guy – Volume Twelve’
- Fire Goes Out On BURN NOTICE
- It Almost Was a SUPER FUN NIGHT, Now Off to Bed
- Brooklyn Nine-Nine Opens strong with 'Pilot' episode
- First Thoughts: FOX's Enlisted
- Burn Notice glances over an 'Exit Plan'
- Necessary Roughness gets rough in third new season
- Covert Affairs intrigues with fourth season opener 'Vamos'
- First thoughts: Suits third season opener is about loyalty
- Wilfred attempts to 'Comfort' us with all the 'Uncertainty'
- Game of Thrones chants "Mhysa" in the season three finale
- The Office tries 'Livin the Dream'
- The Office attempts to build 'Paper Airplanes'
- Meet the cast of 'Survivor: Blood vs. Water', and new twists revealed
- Breaking Bad Season 6 UK Air Date Confirmed For Netflix UK
- Jeff Probst and 'Survivor' snubbed yet again by the Primetime Emmys
- E4 confirm Skins series 7 air date
- Sky Living Supernatural Season 8 UK Air Date
- Hemlock Grove renewed for a 2nd season by Netflix
- The Walking Dead Season 3 UK Channel 5 Air Date
- LoveFilm secure UK rights for Emily Owens M.D.
- Scandal UK air date for season 2 confirmed by More4
- New Girl Season 2 E4 Air Date Confirmed
- The Mindy Project E4 Air Date Confirmed
- 'The Jeff Probst Show' has been cancelled
- The Mentalist Returns To Channel 5 With Series 5 Part 2 This February
- Doctor Who Return For Series 7 Part 2 This March
- FX's The Americans Coming to UK on ITV
- Can Lightning Strike Twice for...
- Throne Beseiged By Pirates
- Why ‘Once Upon a Time’ Is ...
- 2013 Disney Blu-ray Gift Guide
- 2013 ‘Doctor Who’ Gift Gui...
- Back to TV’s Roots
- ABC's Split Season
- How To Be a TV Reviewer
- R.I.P. Finn Hudson
- TV Neglects Independence Day
- DVD Return Policies Need a Cha...
- Fickle TV Fans
- When Good Shows Go Bad
- Will Amazon Change Television?
- Top 5 British TV dramas